Wait…Why Did I Agree to That? Why the Patient Centered Standard Under the Doctrine of Informed Consent Should Be Applied to Pelvic Exams in Asymptomatic Women

Lily Burdick

UNC School of Law, US.

Volume 2025 · December 28, 2025 · pp. 1–31

Download article PDF
DOI: https://doi.org/10.55574/jopx9467

Abstract

In 2020, Columbia University OBGYN Robert Hadden was arrested for a second time for sexually abusing his patients. By the end of 2020, at least 245 women had accused Hadden of abuse over multiple decades. While most licensed physicians do not sexually abuse patients, the scope of the abuse is difficult to determine. This is because hospitals, clinics, and fellow doctors fail to report misconduct, medical boards handle complaints privately, and most significantly, many patients are misinformed as to when pelvic care is medically beneficial and what to expect during pelvic examinations. As a result, most such abuse is never reported. Moreover, even when pelvic care abuses are reported, patients face insurmountable legal hurdles that often preclude relief in civil suits. This paper argues that the doctrine of informed consent can fundamentally shift the dynamic between patients and doctors in pelvic care, helping to prevent gynecological abuses before they occur. Currently, some jurisdictions apply a “customary professional practice standard” to assess whether a physician has adequately informed a patient about a medical procedure—specifically, pelvic exams—based on prevailing practices among medical professionals. This paper contends that this standard is inadequate for pelvic care. Instead, it advocates for state legislatures and courts to adopt a patient-centered informed consent standard. Such a shift would better inform patients, empower them to make more autonomous decisions about their care, and help to address the power imbalances between patients and physicians that can contribute to physician misconduct.

Keywords Health; Women; Gender; Pelvic Exams; Healthcare; Informed Consent; Medical Malpractice

The volume copyright notice sets out the author’s rights and the CC BY 4.0 license.