Julia Mahoney
Mitchell Hamline School of Law, US.
Volume 2025 · December 28, 2025 · pp. 105–127
Download article PDF
DOI: https://doi.org/10.55574/sfap6889
Abstract
As a three-time gesational surrogate and a current law student, I have a unique view on surrogacy laws and regulations. The accessibility of commercial surrogacy is surrounded by uncertainty and controversy, which has a great impact on hopeful intended parents and where they choose to begin their surrogacy journey. Additionally, laws regarding using a surrogate for assisted reproductive technology (ART) are rapidly changing, making the decision more complex and confusing. This paper starts with my own experiences with surrogacy in different states to provide a backdrop and some context for why surrogacy regulations matter. I continue with a brief overview of surrogacy in the United States and a couple of the most influential cases. Next, I consider the arguments presented for federal vs. state legislation. I end the paper with suggested legislation for surrogacy contracts at the state level, providing reasoning to overcome many of the common anti-surrogacy arguments. I look to the state of Minnesota to provide background and context. However, the proposed legislation is relevant to many states in a similar position as Minnesota, having no current surrogacy legislation.
Keywords Surrogate; Surrogacy; Assisted Reproductive Technology; ART; Fertility; Legislation; Minnesota
The volume copyright notice sets out the author’s rights and the CC BY 4.0 license.
