Soft Tissue, Hard Truths: An Ethical Overview of Case Management and a Call to Reject Overtreatment
Pankti Fadia and Walter Champion
Pankti Fadia, South Texas College of Law Houston, US; Walter Champion, South Texas College of Law Houston, US.
Volume 2025 · December 28, 2025 · pp. 58–82
Download article PDF
DOI: https://doi.org/10.55574/manr2791
Abstract
This paper explores the evidentiary role of chiropractic treatment in commercial motor vehicle collision (MVC) litigation, with a focus on its effectiveness in proving causation and damages while avoiding the pitfalls of overtreatment often associated with invasive medical procedures such as injections and unnecessary surgeries. This paper is a practical guide for attorneys to successfully incorporate research-based chiropractic treatment for 18-wheeler collision victims. The paper provides an in-depth analysis of chiropractic practice in the context of personal injury. It examines the whole arch of case management, from evidence-based, cost-effective, non-invasive, drug-free chiropractic rehabilitation treatments to ascertaining valuable expert testimony in jury trials. The paper further evaluates the admissibility of chiropractic testimony under Daubert and Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, and considers the challenges posed by insurance bias and jury skepticism toward chiropractic professionals. Despite these hurdles, chiropractors play a critical role, providing long-term, function-focused rehabilitation that juries increasingly accept when properly presented. Using case law, scholarly sources, and clinical research, this analysis demonstrates that chiropractic evidence is not only legally valid but ethically preferable in commercial vehicle collision litigation. The paper serves as a practical and ethical guideline for personal injury attorneys to successfully leverage chiropractic care to prove causation and damages effectively and persuasively in court.
Keywords Personal Injury; Chiropractic, Chiropractors; Expert Witness; 18-Wheeler, Motor Vehicle Collision; Medical Bills and Records; Past Medical Damages; Daubert Qualification; Chiropractic Practice; Commercial Collision Cases; Auto Insurance; Mass Torts; Plaintiff Personal Injury; Case Management; Medical Management; Doctors of Chiropractic; Physical Therapy; Rehab; Health; RICO; Insurance Fraud; Ethics
The volume copyright notice sets out the author’s rights and the CC BY 4.0 license.
